AI Agencies: The Definitive Guide to Hiring a Real Expert and Avoiding the Hype

Artificial Intelligence is everywhere. Suddenly, hundreds of new agencies and freelancers have appeared, all promising to transform your business. With tools that allow anyone to create a professional website in minutes, it's harder than ever to distinguish a true strategic partner from someone who is simply chasing the latest trend.

The risk is enormous: a poor choice not only means a loss of money but also of time, and it can leave your business processes in a worse state than before.

So, as a business owner, how do you navigate this new and confusing market? What should you look for before hiring an AI or automation service?

This guide is your checklist. We will give you a clear action plan so you can research, evaluate, and confidently choose the right technology partner to take your company to the next level.

Phase 1: The Basic Verification (The "Legal Algorithm" Test)

Before evaluating their expertise, check if they are a legitimate entity. This should take you 5 minutes and will save you many headaches.

1. Are They a Real Company?

Look for the "Legal Notice" or "Terms and Conditions" section on their website. A serious company will always display its fiscal data: full legal name, tax ID number, and a physical address. If this information isn't public or is hard to find, it's a major first red flag.

2. Review the Privacy Policy

Data management is the foundation of AI. Their privacy policy should not be a generic copy-pasted text. It should specify how they handle client data and website user data in compliance with GDPR. A detailed privacy policy is a sign of professionalism.

Phase 2: Evaluating Real Expertise (Beyond the Pretty Website)

Anyone can have an attractive website. As we saw in our guide on Webflow modern tools make design much easier. But real experience is harder to fake.

1. Verifiable Case Studies and Testimonials

Don't settle for a collage of company logos. Look for detailed case studies. Do they explain the initial problem, the process they followed, and the measurable results? (e.g., "we increased qualified leads by 40%," "we reduced response time by 90%"). Testimonials on LinkedIn are also a good indicator of authenticity.

2. Do They Practice What They Preach?

Analyze their own business. What is their own sales process like? Do they use a chatbot or Conversational AI to qualify their own leads? If an agency sells marketing automation, but their own marketing is manual and slow, it's a clear contradiction.

3. Do They Have a Defined Process?

A real expert can explain their methodology. Ask them to describe their process to automate tasks. They should talk about an analysis phase, a workflow design phase, an implementation phase, and an optimization phase. If they only talk about the automation tools they use, they are likely selling technology, not solutions. This is a key point we explore in our guide on process automation.

Phase 3: The Conversation That Defines Everything (The Sales Call)

The first meeting is the ultimate test. Here are the key questions you should ask to unmask a hype vendor:

• Question about Strategy (not tools):
  • Don't ask: "What software do you use?"
  • Ask: "Based on what I've told you about my business, what would be your initial strategic approach?"An expert will talk about your business problems; a novice will talk about the features of their favorite software.
• Question about Results and Measurement:
  • Don't ask: "How much does it cost?" (at the beginning).
  • Ask: "How do you propose we measure the success and ROI of this project?"A serious agency must have a clear answer about the KPIs (Key Performance Indicators) that will be monitored.
• Question about Flexibility:
  • Ask: "What happens if my needs change mid-project? Is your solution scalable?"This will allow you to see if they offer rigid solutions or if they are a flexible partner capable of adapting.

Conclusion: Look for a Partner, Not a Vendor

In the new AI economy, choosing an agency is one of the most critical decisions. You're not just buying software; you're investing in a partner who will have access to your company's internal processes.

Take your time, do your research, and above all, trust those who focus on your business outcomes, not on their own technology.

At Solumize, transparency is our pillar. If you want to see what our process is like and if we can help you, schedule a no-obligation session. We'll be happy to answer all these questions and more.

Schedule a Free Diagnostic Session

‍